Case study: Paediatrician’s conduct is called into question by patient’s parents
Post date: 26/06/2023 | Time to read article: 2 minsThe information within this article was correct at the time of publishing. Last updated 28/06/2023
Dr O’Hare contacted Medical Protection when she received a complaint from a patient’s parents regarding her conduct.
Dr Frances O’Hare* contacted Medical Protection when she received a complaint from a patient’s parents regarding her conduct. Dr O’Hare, a Consultant Community Paediatrician, had undertaken a safeguarding medical following a request from social services. She had never been the subject of a significant complaint before.
Her medical had concluded that further radiological investigations were required and arranged those with the local hospital. However, the parents alleged that she did not properly advise them of the nature of the medical nor investigations. They also alleged that Dr O’Hare accused them of physically assaulting their child. In their complaint letter, the parents threatened to refer Dr O’Hare to the GMC.
What happened next?
How Medical Protection helped
A case file was opened, and Dr O’Hare’s draft complaint response was reviewed. She was given advice to ensure that she provided a chronological account of her involvement in the patient’s care. The medicolegal consultant (MLC) reviewed the anonymised documents and met with Dr O’Hare to support her with reflections in this case. Their discussion focused particularly on reflection around the communication with the parents. Dr O’Hare also carefully explained that her role when undertaking a child protection medical is not to ascertain who is to blame, but to opine on whether the injuries could be non-accidental.
Dr O’Hare’s complaint response, was combined with the Trust’s overall complaint response, and the MLC advised Dr O’Hare that she should request some amendments to the Trust’s letter, so that it more accurately reflected her position.
How did it end?
Take aways
NHS Consultants often need support from Medical Protection to help them respond to complaints. In particular, identifying areas of reflection can be difficult when faced with concerns raised either by a patient or family. Medical Protection’s team are experienced in providing targeted advice on reflection and remediation.
Medical Protection also provides support with GMC investigations; something which is not available through a Trust. In this case our advice on reflection and remediation was critical in ensuring that the case was closed at an early stage. However, should it be required, we also provide legal support throughout a GMC case.
By Claire Harrison, Medicolegal Consultant at Medical Protection
Not a member already? Click here to join
*Names and locations have been changed to protect member confidentiality.
